St. Louis Gooey Butter Cakes

Happy Hump Day Everyone!!! Boy has it been a rough couple of weeks but have no fear I am still around and today I will be bringing you a regional favorite that you may not be aware of if you have never been to the Midwest. Although I haven’t visited my hometown of Dubuque, Iowa in a while, I still remember some of the regions favorites… Taco pizza from Happy Joe’s, Maid Rite Sandwiches, Chicago Style Coney Dogs, and for dessert the Gooey Butter Cake of St. Louis, Missouri. This quirky dessert is a favorite of St. Louisans  and according to the area bakeries it is an acquired taste of the locals. I gave it a shot and I must say was surprised at how delicious it is. Now there are two different types of Gooey Butter Cake. The first is one with a cake batter/cake mix bottom with the gooey layer up top. This is often found in St. Louis supermarkets, restaurants, and made by the home baker as it is easier than the original. However that type of Gooey Butter Cake is more like a chewy and messy bar cookie rather than a delicious cake. The original formula for Gooey Butter Cake resembles an old-fashioned coffee cake base made up of yeast dough and topped with a gooey custard. The second type of Gooey Butter Cake is the one you see in the photos and is worthy of regional recognition. As popular as the Gooey Butter Cake is it comes as no surprise that there are many claims to its fame in St. Louis. Several bakeries were making it years and years ago but two particular families have their own stories claiming they made the original and all the other bakeries followed suit after it’s popularity peaked. The most accepted origin of the cake is that it occurred by accident in the 1930’s by a German-American St. Louis baker who was attempting to make a regular cake but reversed the proportions of certain ingredients. The bakery owner, John Hoffman, had hired a new baker who certainly messed up the formula and created this concoction. Being that it was during the Great Depression, a little screw up was a big deal and so rather than throw out the large amount of screwed up cake, they decided to sell it. Surprisingly it became a huge hit at the bakery and so then they were forced to try to duplicate it. Once it was duplicated they began selling the Gooey Butter Cake as a staple item of their bakery and other bakeries nearby followed suit, creating St. Louis’ most popular ethnic treat. I have chosen two produce two flavors of Gooey Butter Cake, Butterscotch and Chocolate, although there are several more flavors you could experiment with and try. The classic flavor is vanilla and that formula I will provide below. I will also provide the alterations to the original formula so that you can also produce the Butterscotch and Chocolate varieties seen in the photographs. A few quick notes before I leave you… Be sure to remove the cake from the oven when the perimeter is golden brown and the center jiggles when gently shaken. The topping will continue to set up with residual heat as the cake cools. The secret ingredients in this formula that are not exactly traditional but allow ease for the home baker to recreate the original in a snap are light corn syrup and Instant Pudding mixes. These two ingredients quality are crucial. The corn syrup aids in the gooey topping and the instant pudding adds flavor, sweetness, and structure to the gooey topping that would otherwise be much harder to achieve. I suggest using Karo brand corn syrup and Jell-O brand Instant Pudding for best results.

St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake

Ingredients

  • ¼ cup Milk; heated to 110°
  • 1 ½ tsp. Rapid-Rise or Instant Yeast
  • ¾ cup Sugar; divided
  • 3 Large Eggs; divided
  • 1 ½ tsp. Pure Vanilla Extract; divided
  • ½ tsp. Sea Salt
  • 1½ cups Bread Flour
  • 10 tbsp. Unsalted Butter; softened & 6 of the tbsp. cut into pieces
  • 2 oz. Cream Cheese; softened
  • 2 tbsp. Light Corn Syrup
  • 1/3 cup All-Purpose Flour
  • 3 tbsp. Instant Vanilla Pudding Mix
  • 2 tbsp. Confectioners’ Sugar

Directions

  1. For the Dough: Adjust oven rack to the lower-middle position. Preheat oven to 200°. When the oven has preheated, turn it off and keep the door closed. Line an 8 inch square baking pan with parchment. Grease the parchment and a medium sized bowl. Set aside.
  2. In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, mix the milk and yeast on low speed until the yeast dissolves. Add ¼ cup sugar, 2 eggs, ½ tsp. vanilla, salt, and bread flour. Mix until combined. Increase the speed to medium-low and add 6 tbsp. of butter, one piece at a time, until incorporated. Continue to mix for 5 minutes.
  3. Transfer dough to prepared bowl, cover with plastic, and place in the warmed oven. Allow the dough to rise until it has doubled in size, about 30 minutes. Spread the dough into the prepared pan.
  4. For the Topping: Preheat oven to 350°. In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat the remaining ½ cup sugar, 4 tbsp. butter, and cream cheese on medium speed until light and fluffy, about 2 minutes. Reduce speed to low and add the corn syrup, remaining egg, and 1 tsp. vanilla. Beat until combined. Add the all-purpose flour and pudding mix. Blend until just incorporated. Portion dollops of topping evenly over batter, then spread into an even layer.
  5. Bake until exterior is golden and center of topping is just beginning to color, about 25 minutes. Note that the center will still jiggle slightly when the pan is shook so do not overbake. Cool in the pan at least 3 hours. Use the overhang of the parchment to lift the cake out of the pan. Dust the cake with confectioners’ sugar. Serve immediately. If the entire cake is not consumed, it can be refrigerated for 2 days
  6. Alternate Chocolate Version: The recipe above is for the original vanilla flavor. To prepare the chocolate version, simply make the following adjustments to the formula above. In the dough, replace 3 tbsp. of the bread flour with an equal amount of Dutch-processed cocoa powder. In the topping, replace 3 tbsp. of the instant vanilla pudding mix with an equal amount of instant chocolate fudge pudding mix.
  7. Alternate Butterscotch Version: The recipe above is for the original vanilla flavor. To prepare the butterscotch version, simply make the following adjustments to the formula above. In the dough, replace ¼ cup sugar for an equal amount of packed light brown sugar. In the topping, replace 3 tbsp. of the instant vanilla pudding mix with an equal amount of instant butterscotch pudding mix.

 

Special Thanks To:

 

C. Rich

Peter Mendoros – Photography

Jello Brand Pudding © 2012 Kraft Foods

Karo Brand Syrup © 2012 ACH Food Companies, Inc.

 

All remaining content © Honeybee’s Patisserie 2012

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.